Murder! (1930)

When a woman is convicted of murder, one of the jurors selected to serve on the murder-trial jury believes the accused, an aspiring actress, is innocent of the crime and takes it upon himself to apprehend the real killer.

Eduardo Nasi

That's a nice movie.

Some actings in the beginning seem too affected, but the ending is so good that, by there, you'll have forgiven the first scenes.

12 years ago

ClassicLady

Can't go wrong with Hitchcock or Herbert Marshall.

11 years ago

Siskoid

What if Henry Fonda was bullied to come up with the same verdict as everyone else in 12 Angry Men? And then felt so guilty about it that he spent the next few days trying to solve the theater-related crime before an innocent woman goes to the gallows? That's essentially the premise of Murder!, a very early Hitchcock talkie that has its charms - the jury deliberations, the gallows humor, seeing the play from backstage, the tense audition scene - but generally jumps around too much for it to work as an effective whodunit. Herbert Marshall makes a good effete detective - an actor himself so he can read people - and there's value in showing how the police in this case were lazy in their pursuit of the evidence. I don't know why Norah Baring (as the accused Diana… ALSO Baring? That's so weird!) is so ethereal. I suppose this is from the book being adapted that she doesn't really defend herself, but you never really connect with the character and therefore neither care nor believe people are so taken with her. What tricks Hitchcock 'ports over from silent film-making are interesting, but this is one of his lower-tier efforts.

a year ago

More info & statistics

1.5% of the viewers favorited this title, 1.5% disliked it

This title has never been in an official list

Activity

John Garfield checked this title

a week ago

Ccadenelli checked this title

2 weeks ago

matthewpchen checked this title

a month ago

ESG checked this title

a month ago

dagn96 checked this title

a month ago

muhfn checked this title

2 months ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

Alfred Hitchcock...

54 movies · At #12

Guide for the Film Fanatic

1644 movies · At #963

Alfred Hitchcock...

59 movies · At #13

Dictionary of Films...

1515 movies · At #860

Guide For The Film...

4208 movies · At #964

A Comprehensive...

3249 movies · At #1942

5001 Nights at the...

2755 movies · At #1632

The Celluloid...

479 movies · At #269

Leonard Maltin's...

3251 movies · At #1850

The Most Popular...

100 movies · At #5

Andrew Sarris' The...

685 movies · At #396

iCM Forum's Favorite...

3055 movies · At #734

iCM Forum's Favorite...

1198 movies · At #753

TSPDT Top 25 Films...

250 movies · At #18

noir nominations

1583 movies · At #1197

The Best Films...

1392 movies · At #96

Deleuze Cinema

651 movies · At #382

Plex: All movies...

5000 movies · At #744

Cinéma de Minuit

1662 movies · At #533

iCM Forum's...

1283 movies · At #778

TCM January 2025

429 movies · At #223

Herbert Marshall...

96 movies · At #3

My Movies

3542 movies · At #3224

Continental Catalogue

303 movies · At #239

Criterion Channel...

52 movies · At #30