1917 (2019)

At the height of the First World War, two young British soldiers must cross enemy territory and deliver a message that will stop a deadly attack on hundreds of soldiers.

Siskoid

Is 1917 a good title for something that takes place over a day? (And indeed, is almost 2 hours in real time given the one-shot conceit, though director Sam Mendes does find ways to contract time.) Lets talk about that conceit because it exacerbates the completely legitimate comparison to an MMO side-quest. The story is so streamlined - it's this one, very simple mission - that it's basically an NPC giving the player a quest and off we go. With the camera never cutting away from the main character and following him through the adventure, often over the shoulder, the visual vocabulary is somewhat like that of a third-person sandbox/shooter. Does it really intensify immersion into the story? Maybe. I kind of think Mendes gave himself and his cast and crew a big challenge for us to marvel at as TECHNIQUE and that's all there is to it, but that's fine. We DO marvel at it. If there is a point to the single shot, it may be to show war as a continuous and relentless experience, here crunched into 24/2 hours for our convenience, a temporal prison for men who just want to go home but are afraid they can't connect to that other timeline. More importantly and all that said, it works, with a couple of stand-out moments (the flare run and the final sequence through to the end and bookend especially) and given the brief scenes with the characters NOT on the mission (you can't exactly go back to keep track of them), it's especially wonderful that they each leave such impressions (and not just the ones who are name-brand actors). My personal favorites are the hilarious Andrew Scott and that big fat rat.

5 months ago

aniforprez

Absolutely incredible. An exhausting, somber, grim war movie made with some of the best talent on all fronts especially the cinematography done by the absolutely brilliant Roger Deakins

5 months ago

baraka92

Finally someone not named Cuarón or Lubezki knows how to use the one shot ”gimmick” effectively in an action setting. There’s a deeply humane idea behind it.

This deserves to be watch on the biggest screen with the best sound you can find.

5 months ago

More info & statistics

9.7% of the viewers favorited this title, 0.4% disliked it

Currently in 9 official lists, but has been in 10

Activity

PKing checked this title

3 hours ago

Luthien_ checked this title

4 hours ago

scttswnsn checked this title

8 hours ago

supercodes checked this title

13 hours ago

EnzoMR2 checked this title

16 hours ago

OneSixthRoy checked this title

19 hours ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

IMDb's War Top 50

50 movies · At #10

IMDb's 2010s Top 50

50 movies · At #14

BAFTA Award - Best Film

74 movies · At #74

IMDb's Top 250

250 movies · At #89

Academy Award - Best...

122 movies · At #122

Golden Globe Award -...

151 movies · At #151

Box Office Mojo's...

1000 movies · At #354

Academy Award - Best...

566 movies · At #564

Box Office Mojo's...

1000 movies · At #845