dombrewer

This odd thriller sits uncomfortably next to the great Hitchcock thrillers of two years previous and two years after (Rear Window and Vertigo respectively), given it shares a lot with both- lovely camera work, Jimmy Stewart in the lead, and another fantastic Bernard Hermann score- perhaps one of the best. It's a shame the plot is so weak by comparison, or that we have to watch Doris Day singing all of "Que Sera Sera" twice. The Albert Hall sequence is famous, but oddly pedestrian… we wait, like the gunman, for the moment to arrive and thoughts begin to creep in…

Why do we care about this rotund foreign prime minister? How in earth is the gunman going to accurately hit his target from that distance with a tiny handgun? There must be easier ways to assassinate someone than with 5000 potential witnesses. A cymbal crash won't actually be louder than a bullet will it? Is Doris just going to stand there crying for the entire sequence?

After that it all gets sillier, the finale baffingly prosaic followed by a misjudged coda. For all that there's a lot to enjoy- Hitch is still in full control but the material seriously lets him down

12 years ago

DisneyStitch

After watching half a dozen Hitchcock films you get the kind of flavor that he had as a director. This particular film by him comes off as just… flat footed is the best word I can come up with. The dialog isn't quite up to par and the Stewart/Day coupling doesn't have any pop to it. Nothing even close to the relationships that Hitchcock masterfully crafted in say Rear Window or even Vertigo for that matter. Not a terrible movie but it gets a bad rep because Hitchcock has set the bar unbelievably high.

9 years ago

SLionsCricket

Fails to capture the magic of other Hitchcock films (excluding his four giant masterpieces) For eg: The 39 Steps does a much better job at its story than this does of it. However, Stewart's performance is fantastic and the usual level of Hitchcock suspense, though not fully built, is enough to make this a decent but somewhat forgettable film even if the song isn't!

11 years ago

More info & statistics

4.9% of the viewers favorited this title, 0.5% disliked it

This title has been in 1 official lists

Activity

Sataa42 checked this title

2 days ago

starlight-queen checked this title

5 days ago

eraserhead1976 checked this title

5 days ago

Ccadenelli checked this title

a week ago

McDone added this title to their watchlist

a week ago

Clouis checked this title

a week ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

Alfred Hitchcock...

54 movies · At #44

Every Film That Has...

1346 movies · At #423

1001 movies you must...

1398 movies · At #322

James Stewart filmography

79 movies · At #52

In Competition at Cannes

1615 movies · At #1428

1001 Movies You Must...

237 movies · At #20

Guide for the Film Fanatic

1644 movies · At #890

Alfred Hitchcock...

59 movies · At #49

Histoire(s) du cinéma

385 movies · At #258

Dictionary of Films...

1515 movies · At #618

A Complete List of...

4986 movies · At #1584

Jean-Luc Godard's...

110 movies · At #3

1,000 Best Movies on...

1013 movies · At #551

Guide For The Film...

4208 movies · At #891

iCM Forum's Top...

1008 movies · At #847

A Comprehensive...

3249 movies · At #1790

Conspiracy/paranoia...

414 movies · At #17

AFI’s 100 Years …...

91 movies · At #46

All Oscar-Nominated...

3124 movies · At #1154

Dizionario dei...

1244 movies · At #535

Academy Award Music:...

89 movies · At #23

AFI’s Top 10...

50 movies · At #31

MovieMeter Top 1000 - 2021

1000 movies · At #674

Empire's 50 Remakes...

50 movies · At #24

MovieMeter Top 1000 - 2023

1000 movies · At #938