For a debut film that beats out the career peaks from so many other directors, I guess I stumble a bit when I hear it being called 'piss-poor'. Even for Dorothy McGuire's quiet and subtle performance alone, this film is clearly good. I found this more moving and true-to-life than On the Waterfront, though not by much. It really grabs you by the soul.

5 years ago


It's not one of my favorite films, but I can't imagine finding a film like this "piss-poor." It's solid filmmaking, with memorable characters and some genuinely moving moments.

7 years ago


Sentimental and endearing, a quintessential Forties masterpiece. James Dunn and Peggy Ann Garner are beyond fantastic.

7 years ago

More info & statistics

7.3% of the viewers favorited this title, 0.8% disliked it

Currently in 4 official lists, but has been in 5

Highest official list rank ever is #17 and lowest is #921


AndrewB checked this title

4 days ago

Simba63 checked this title

5 days ago

albajos checked this title

a week ago

Traveller checked this title

a week ago

george4mon checked this title

a week ago

Andy Gladbach checked this title

2 weeks ago


Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie


50 movies · At #28

National Film Registry

806 movies · At #555

Halliwell's Top...

1043 movies · At #697

The Best 1,000...

1005 movies · At #921