Ménilmontant (1926)

A pair of sisters leave the country for the city after their parents are slaughtered in a mysterious axe murder.


A short French silent forever blessed (or cursed) to be forever connected to Pauline Kael - she stated in an interview that of everything she'd ever watched it was her favourite film of all time. A curse because that might raise some unlikely expectation in some minds, a blessing because it probably wouldn't be as much sought out today if she hadn't given it that lofty accolade - even so it currently still only has a meagre 820 ratings on IMDB. Luckily for us it's readily available on Youtube and it is definitely worth the watch.

Nadia Sibirskaïa is radiant as the wronged woman, the youngest to two orphan girls, following the violent murder of their parents, without guidance lured into a man's bed and then cast aside for her elder sister, leaving her pregnant, alone and desperate. She performs her sorrowful part with admirable naturalism, expertly captured with innovative camera work by director Dimitri Kirsanoff - the scene of her tearfully accepting food given by an old man on a park bench is rightly acclaimed: it's a beautiful piece of acting.

Although some of the early scenes where the sisters play children are a little dubious, the events of the conclusion are oblique and it can be slightly confusing in places without any inter-titles, even for a slight story, the performances and marvellous location cinematography make this a neglected 20s classic deserving of wider rediscovery.

7 years ago


The soundtrack to this film is just fantastic. Love the improvised jazz.

5 years ago

More info & statistics

12.6% of the viewers favorited this title, 0.8% disliked it

Currently in 6 official lists, but has been in 10


Laurens checked this title

3 days ago

Lonesome Tree added this title to their watchlist

5 days ago

LSDFISH checked this title

a week ago

GruesomeTwosome checked this title

2 weeks ago

Onderhond checked this title

3 weeks ago

tazz_85 checked this title

a month ago


Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

TSPDT's Brief Encounters

250 movies · At #51

Paul Rotha's Silent...

338 movies · At #57

Silent Era's The Top...

304 movies · At #175

Anthology Film...

542 movies · At #249

Doubling the Canon

1100 movies · At #584

TSPDT's 1,000...

1004 movies · At #704