TheMajor

Beautiful to watch, but… I assumed that Edgar Allan Poe's highly descriptive and imaginary tales would benefit from a visualized adaptation like this, but the narrative aspect really suffers. Although I have not seen many silent adaptations of his works, silent film may not be the best medium. His tales are best read and visualized in the mind. A film of his works could use a little more darkness, horror and tension.

9 years ago

Dieguito

Yeah @TheMajor! Look what the trivia of IMDb says "Luis Buñuel, who was Assistant Director, quit the picture after clashing with producer/director Jean Epstein over Epstein's decision to basically ignore Edgar Allan Poe's story". Beautiful and dark soundtrack though!

8 years ago

More info & statistics

9% of the viewers favorited this title, 1.3% disliked it

Currently in 8 official lists, but has been in 11

Activity

dombrewer checked this title

5 hours ago

Melvelet added this title to their watchlist

23 hours ago

CoolHandBrandon checked this title

2 days ago

kaculler checked this title

3 days ago

Mattadd checked this title

6 days ago

TenSpadesBeTrump checked this title

6 days ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

Akira Kurosawa's A...

102 movies · At #5

Paul Rotha's Silent...

338 movies · At #38

Jonathan Rosenbaum's...

1133 movies · At #80

TSZDT's The 1,000...

1000 movies · At #120

Roger Ebert's Great Movies

410 movies · At #151

TSPDT's 1,000...

1000 movies · At #159

Silent Era's The Top...

304 movies · At #164

Anthology Film...

542 movies · At #202