Crimson Peak (2015)

In the aftermath of a family tragedy, an aspiring author is torn between love for her childhood friend and the temptation of a mysterious outsider. Trying to escape the ghosts of her past, she is swept away to a house that breathes, bleeds… and remembers.

Siskoid

Crimson Peak looks gorgeous, but it's probably the weakest Guillermo del Toro film I've seen in a while, not that I'd usually commend his films - Pan's Labyrinth aside - for their plots. Though the trailer sells it as a horror story, it's really a Gothic romance with a supernatural element, and it mostly works as a throwback to that genre. I suppose my problem with it is that the last act falls back on thriller clichés and loses something of its magical qualities. It does hark back to Pan's Labyrinth in that it tries to layer in an ambiguous reality - how much of the story happened and how much was Edith's fiction? - but that puzzle, if you want to call it one, is slight, its impact on the film negligible. Similarly, if this were a true Gothic romance, the ghosts would be figments of the imagination, not real. The film tries to be ambiguous about this, but in the final analysis really isn't. That said, it is beautifully directed and designed, this story of aristocrats clinging to the literalized open wound of their sins as represented by their decaying house. Jane Eyre meets The Fall of the House of Usher, with Tom Hiddleston's butt for good measure.

4 years ago

Boei

Style over substance. And even the style was not impressive. Very weak plot, simple and boring. Nothing special…

4 years ago

jcoatney

If you're familiar with Bluebeard, The Bloody Chamber, Rebecca, Jane Eyre, etc., then you know where the film is going to go.

However that didn't prevent me from enjoying it. Jessica Chastain really makes the movie. 7/10

4 years ago

More info & statistics

4.5% of the viewers favorited this title, 2% disliked it

This title has never been in an official list

Activity

CatchTheBirdie favorited this title

15 hours ago

davydesmet checked this title

yesterday

Takeru checked this title

2 days ago

nips_ checked this title

6 days ago

lytesabre checked this title

a week ago

Crashley128 checked this title

a week ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

iCM Forum's Top 250...

250 movies · At #207

The 21st Century’s...

250 movies · At #172

The Best Horror Movies

683 movies · At #681

TSZDT 1001-2000

1000 movies · At #47

iCM Forum's...

4529 movies · At #503

Jessica Chastain...

31 movies · At #10

LWLies Recommends*

1100 movies · At #453

Arrow Video Releases (UK)

470 movies · At #362

Guillermo del Toro Films

12 movies · At #12

2015 in Film

660 movies · At #525

MovieMeter Top 1000 - 2019

1000 movies · At #745

iCM Forum's...

2593 movies · At #207

iCM Forum's...

1000 movies · At #410

Arrow Video USA Releases

299 movies · At #195

iCM Forum's Favorite...

2312 movies · At #1153

The A.V. Club Yearly...

251 movies · At #155

All Horror Movies...

350 movies · At #251

Saturn Award for...

44 movies · At #42

Tom Hiddleston Filmography

16 movies · At #14

Film Fanatic Book...

4997 movies · At #2137

iCM Forum's...

1034 movies · At #183

MovieMeter Top...

778 movies · At #173

Ebbywebby's favorite...

228 movies · At #77

TSZDT: 21st Century...

1562 movies · At #172

Fantastic Fest

522 movies · At #161