franzekafky

The atmosphere, colours, music… all splendidly produced. However, for the sake of these elements, the director seems to have disregarded many essential elements in the book (or, in the real story for that matter).

The film can barely convey to the spectators the agony Michael Kohlhaas suffers, or how he could raise a small-scale army, how viciously he had been treated by the authorities, how he had to endure countless treasons and backstabbings, how royal/family ties and self interests prevail above all else (especially justice: justice is but a mere word), etc. The director and screenwriter also ignored the immensenly important Martin Luther's influence, sympathy, philosophy on Kohlhaas' case. Even in the film cast, he is referred as "the theologist".

Poor, very poor screenwriting, very poor character development - even description -, but close-to-perfect directorship of photography!

9 years ago

Siskoid

A French redress of a German story, Michael Kohlhass might be a recognizable name in central Europe - he's a folk hero that's halfway between Robin Hood and Braveheart - but not here, so of course they saddled it with an overwrought title: Age of Uprising: The Legend of Michael Kohlhaas. Yeah, that's not gonna turn it into a hit, guys. One thing I've learned looking at Mads Mikkelsen's career is that the last character you want to be in his films is his wife. He plays a horse trader who gets cheated by the new baron, refuses to back down, and that costs him his wife. It's a great little story of injustice, with Mads as usual extremely watchable. Unfortunately, the peasant revolt Kohlhass leads is the boring part. The action beats are good, but there seems to be too much going on behind the scenes and we're often following characters we don't rightly know. Is there a longer version where these people's scenes make sense? Your attention wanders just when you should feel roused. But then, this is bound to be a downer, unless the aristocracy was taken down in the 16th Century and our history books are wrong. Special mention of Denis Lavant as a priest who really embodies how religion was keeping the citizenry under control then (as perhaps, now).

9 months ago

Emiam

6/10

Exciting and critically acclaimed at film festivals, nice with few dialogues and beautiful environments, but something is missing for higher ratings. Filmed many times before this truth-based story.

6 years ago

More info & statistics

3% of the viewers favorited this title, 1.7% disliked it

This title has never been in an official list

Activity

Morx666 checked this title

2 weeks ago

olympe7 checked this title

3 weeks ago

tugrulakca checked this title

2 months ago

eimraa checked this title

4 months ago

eles checked this title

4 months ago

Magus checked this title

7 months ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

In Competition at Cannes

1615 movies · At #110

Explore French Cinema

1030 movies · At #989

2014 in Film

689 movies · At #281

Beyond Hollywood:...

687 movies · At #189

The Dissolve 4 Stars...

125 movies · At #79

Caesar Awards -...

771 movies · At #103

Film Fanatic Book...

4998 movies · At #4350

Mads Mikkelsen filmography

42 movies · At #33

Cannes Festival 2013

21 movies · At #15

Viennale

1479 movies · At #354

Every Films That Has...

561 movies · At #445

A list of films I...

508 movies · At #459

Available online...

3180 movies · At #1614

Contains animal cruelty

1821 movies · At #388

Festival de Cannes -...

1894 movies · At #1626

Nightingale family...

1192 movies · At #692

Available online...

3670 movies · At #2894

Césars Nominees...

538 movies · At #379

15th Mumbai Film...

140 movies · At #35

500<400 - 2021 Edition

400 movies · At #395

Favourite Films of...

1694 movies · At #601

SensCritique best...

98 movies · At #77