Nattvardsgästerna (1963)

a.k.a Winter Light

A Swedish pastor fails a loving woman, a suicidal fisherman and God.

V012

Such a fun film. Bring the kids.

10 years ago

pitchorneirda

I guess all protestantism is contained in this film.

11 years ago

Siskoid

Winter Light, Ingmar Bergman's exploration of faith and doubt stars Gunnar Björnstrand as a troubled pastor, Tomas, just going through the motions and hearing nothing but silence from God. Set between two services, mere hours apart, this is an intimate and subtle piece that could have been done as a play. What most jumps out at me is Tomas' hubris, a function of the first Deadly Sin pride, and the reason he feels cut off from his own spirituality. In one telling speech, he admits that his naive younger self became a clergyman because he saw God as a function of himself, an ideal that seemed only possible to a young man. Now that he has suffered, he doubts, if not God's existence, then God's interest in humanity. Fact is, he's still interpreting God through himself. He tries to comfort a suicidal man, but can't because he is himself despondent. A woman loves him, but he hates her for reminding him of his dead wife. He rejects her love just as he rejects God's, indeed just as he rejects his idealistic self. If the Divine Spark is in ourselves, and each person their own God or echo of God (according to your beliefs), the Tomas' nihilism is laced with self-hatred, which he projects onto the people in his life and his God. Pride not as self-love, but as self-hatred. Does he, by the end, reconnect? Some have called the ending ambiguous. I rather think he continues to miss the point of the lessons he should learn through the course of the film. At the end, the cycle merely repeats. Or am I projecting my own attitudes upon it?

5 years ago

More info & statistics

14.5% of the viewers favorited this title, 0.8% disliked it

Currently in 10 official lists, but has been in 14

Activity

lila50 checked this title

8 hours ago

eraserhead1976 checked this title

2 days ago

sebasda checked this title

5 days ago

Belladonna_of_Sadness checked this title

5 days ago

punkfrud checked this title

a week ago

muppetface checked this title

a week ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

FLM's Best Swedish...

106 movies · At #17

iCheckMovies's 1960s...

100 movies · At #24

Cahiers du Cinéma's...

614 movies · At #114

iCheckMovies's Most...

250 movies · At #143

The Criterion Collection

1542 movies · At #252

Mark Cousins's The...

522 movies · At #260

Roger Ebert's Great Movies

410 movies · At #316

Sight & Sound's The...

1022 movies · At #395

TSPDT's 1,000...

1001 movies · At #433

Time Out's 1000...

1201 movies · At #960