Timec

Finally, those who would reject those artists of "realist" art are denying some of the best of what film, art, and human expression in general can offer to the world. For it is in such art that some of the greatest expressions of compassion and understanding of the human condition are to be found. Such art is one of the highest forms of human expression, for it reminds us of mankind's duty to help those in need. In the best cases (as with this film), it shakes us out of our apathy, it forces us to confront what we would otherwise choose to ignore.

No, simply watching a film does not fix the world - but it can lead to great things, for the feelings that it instills in you can, and have (in my case, and in the case of others I know) inspire us to create change, to help those around us. They (without glorifying or reveling in poverty or violence or other evils) show us the very human nature of those who have been shut out by society.

Those like aneic would like to deny art's ability to affect people, and to create hope (not the artificial, false hope of a "Slumdog Millionaire" or "Life Is Beautiful," but a more lasting and real hope of a brighter future) - by shining a light in some of the darkest places of our society, they help guide us toward something better.

Sorry for the essay, but the sentiments expressed in aneic's post are incredibly misguided, and I felt the need to correct them.

8 years ago

armyofshadows

My opinion will certainly be disagreed with, but I didn't like this one, or even Paisan for that matter. Rome, Open City is a masterpiece, but this film I found to be predictable and very pessimistic, in a way that betrays the true spirit of great neorealist films.

6 years ago

Timec

But I can understand your motivation, Aneic. You desperately want what you said to be true, because then you can avoid responsibility for failing to confront the reality you have been presented with ("Well, the filmmakers are, uh, enjoying it and stuff.") Unfortunately for you, the aforementioned films of Scorsese and Rossellini and de Sica are far more honest in their depictions and motivations than truly self-serving and dishonest films like "Life Is Beautiful" and "Slumdog Millionaire." Any strong "uplift" in films such as "Berlin Year Zero" or "Bicycle Thieves" would have been hugely damaging to the films' integrity. That is to say, the so-called "hysterics" and "sullenness" of this film are more than well-earned (anything else than a "sullen" tone would have been a very bad choice,) considering the nature of the story.

That's certainly not to suggest that all "depressing" films are inherently more honest than uplifting ones, but a "realist" style does not, in fact, come with the baggage that you would assign it. The choice to focus on such subject matter is not dishonest or hypocritical, as ones interest in a given subject does not have to be motivated by pleasure derived from that subject, but may just as well be motivated by genuine human interest and compassion. Yes, there are other great films that are much happier, even joyous (see: "Singin' in the Rain," "Kiki's Delivery Service," etc.) but it is necessary that some great filmmakers choose to focus on subjects that would fall outside of your range of interest (besides the fact that Rossellini and de Sica have proven themselves more than capable of making far less "sullen" films - see "Miracle in Milan" for one great example.)

8 years ago

More info & statistics

9.4% of the viewers favorited this title, 1% disliked it

Currently in 9 official lists, but has been in 11

Activity

Kerfoot32 checked this title

yesterday

mehmetcevizci checked this title

5 days ago

benitotambara added this title to their watchlist

a week ago

ghadi checked this title

a week ago

Frankylias checked this title

3 weeks ago

Shosha The Tarnegolet checked this title

3 weeks ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

Locarno Film...

88 movies · At #3

FilmTV's 100...

100 movies · At #16

The 100 Most...

102 movies · At #78

Il Grande Cinema Italiano

250 movies · At #95

Sight and Sound 2012...

807 movies · At #191

They Shoot Pictures,...

1001 movies · At #226

Jonathan Rosenbaum's...

1133 movies · At #260

Have You Seen? A...

1007 movies · At #359

The Criterion Collection

1214 movies · At #554