Rene Narciso

I loved this movie, I think it's a masterpiece, but I sorta understand how it may be disappointing to some.

I think it really helps if you don't think of it as a comedy. There are plenty of funny bits, but it's not a movie to make you laugh.

It's actually closer to a musical. Some huge, elaborated, complex musical, with magnificent sets, but the song and dance numbers are replaced by the chaos of modern urban life itself.

We get both the malignant aspects of modernity (the first part of the movie) and the benign (the second part).

Oh yeah, and this movie needs to be seen in a huge movie theater screen, not at home.

3 years ago


I'm glad I saw Mr. Hulot's Holiday before this, as Tati's style takes some serious getting used to. But once I got what he was doing (about halfway through Holiday), it became a joy. Here we get the same plot-less, character-less stroll through everyday life, with mild sight gags everywhere, and every frame stuffed full of details. It's got almost a silent comedy vibe, only the focus isn't on blunt slapstick, but friendly observations. I think this one is better constructed than Holiday. The glass-walled, technology-driven aesthetic was great. The first act in the building was an absolute blast. The scene with the glass-walled apartment buildings and the televisions was cool too. And the dinner scene, while the most complex and detail-rich, went on a few minutes too long. Loved the carnival finale. I've really never seen anything else like Tati's films, but I'm anxious to see more.

6 years ago


More tedious than funny

8 years ago

More info & statistics

13.4% of the viewers favorited this title, 1.8% disliked it

Currently in 18 official lists, but has been in 24


Wcm142 checked this title

17 hours ago

mysteryfan checked this title

2 days ago

moopoints checked this title

a week ago

mrockey28 checked this title

a week ago

Jacobae checked this title

a week ago

vjcespedesc checked this title

a week ago


Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

Time Out's The 100...

100 movies · At #7

BBC's The 100...

101 movies · At #8

Sight & Sound's The...

807 movies · At #41

TSPDT's 1,000...

1005 movies · At #49

Cahiers du Cinéma's...

100 movies · At #71

The Criterion Collection

1293 movies · At #116

Harvard's Suggested...

348 movies · At #193

Geoff King's Film Comedy

351 movies · At #243

366 Weird Movies

366 movies · At #251

Roger Ebert's Great Movies

410 movies · At #253

Halliwell's Top...

1043 movies · At #356

Cahiers du Cinéma's...

571 movies · At #435

1001 Movies You Must...

1009 movies · At #465

Jonathan Rosenbaum's...

1133 movies · At #556

The New York Times's...

1001 movies · At #673

David Thomson's Have...

1011 movies · At #684

The Guardian's 1000...

1004 movies · At #703

Time Out's 1000...

1033 movies · At #726