Siskoid

The Navigator has a strong romcom premise: Saboteurs cut a ship adrift, and the only two souls aboard are Buster Keaton and his unrequited love. I'd watch this as a talky! As is, there are a lot of neat bits, though sometimes the set-ups are rather forced, but as long as they allow for Keaton's brand of physical comedy and stuntmanship, who am I to argue? You could say this an hour's worth of Keaton almost drowning, and as usual for him, it looks quite dangerous. In fact, the last act sort of forgets it's a comedy and goes for a big adventure set piece, dated because there's nothing so early-20th as your heroes running from island cannibals, is there? This is in contrast with the film's otherwise cartoony antic. And I mean it. It's a living cartoon, with gags you would expect from the Loony Tunes, especially in the underwater scene heralded by the poster. It's completely ridiculous. Somehow, my favorite bit is one of the simplest ones - Buster trying to shuffle some very wet cards. That one got me good.

a year ago

ux21

This one didn’t click with me as much as i would’ve hoped. Although the ocean liner acts as a great prop for Buster Keaton’s personal brand of mischief, for my own subjective taste, The Navigator is just a bit short on plot, laughs, surprises and only picks up a bit of momentum in the third act. Still an enjoyable, but second rate Buster flick compared with the two masterpieces preceding it.

2 months ago

More info & statistics

6.7% of the viewers favorited this title, 0.5% disliked it

Currently in 13 official lists, but has been in 14

Activity

boutdatsippa checked this title

2 days ago

Mattadd checked this title

3 days ago

leaves312 checked this title

4 days ago

BigMExpress added this title to their watchlist

a week ago

Kordian checked this title

a week ago

Jhonny checked this title

a week ago

Friends

Log in to see which of your friends have seen this movie

BFI's 360 Classic...

365 movies · At #19

David Thomson's Have...

1011 movies · At #36

IMDb's 1920s Top 50

50 movies · At #39

Silent Era's The Top...

304 movies · At #60

AFI's 100...

100 movies · At #81

Paul Rotha's Silent...

338 movies · At #149

Roger Ebert's Great Movies

410 movies · At #196

Halliwell's Top...

1043 movies · At #251

Eureka!'s The...

346 movies · At #320

Amos Vogel's Film as...

597 movies · At #372

Time Out's 1000...

1033 movies · At #647

TSPDT's 1,000...

1005 movies · At #763

Library of...

856 movies · At #799